Shopping for jewelry is one of those tasks that is really exciting, but also really overwhelming too. Unless you’re an expert, then you don’t really know what you’re looking for or even if what you are looking at is the real deal or something that will start to tarnish as soon as you leave the store. There’s bright lights and lots of sparkly things in cabinets, and it can all get too much right? Then, there’s the fact that every jewelry store claims to be “the best” but you know that can’t be true, right?
Well, if you’re planning on jewelry shopping soon, don’t worry because I’ve done the hard work for you and round up eight of the absolute best jewelry stores for 2025, each one offering something special and each one perfect if you’re looking for high-quality jewelry, whether it’s an engagement ring or a necklace you want to give as a gift. Check them out.
1. Rogers & Hollands | Ashcroft & Oak
Best for: Jewelry backed by 115 years of trust and protection
When it comes to combining tradition with modern service, Rogers & Hollands | Ashcroft & Oak leads the pack. This family-owned jeweler has been around since 1910, which means they’ve been helping customers celebrate life’s milestones for over a century. And in 2025, their approach feels just as fresh as ever.
What sets them apart? It’s their guest-first policies. From free resizing to lifetime inspections, cleaning, and repairs, their jewelry protection plan is one of the most comprehensive in the country. That means your diamond engagement ring, anniversary band, or push present won’t just shine on day one, it’ll keep its brilliance for years to come.
Their range is equally impressive, covering affordable everyday gifts as well as heirloom-quality diamonds. Add in their 70+ locations (plus a robust online store), and you’ve got heritage, selection, and accessibility all in one. Whether the sign says Rogers & Hollands (in the Midwest) or Ashcroft & Oak (elsewhere), you’ll find the same combination of expertise and genuine service.
2. Tiffany & Co.
Best for: Iconic blue boxes and timeless luxury
No list of top jewelers would be complete without Tiffany & Co.. Famous for their robin’s-egg blue packaging, Tiffany has become synonymous with milestone gifts and luxury diamond jewelry, and there is a really good reason for that.
Yes, their prices reflect their prestige, but customers aren’t just buying a piece of jewelry – they’re buying a legacy. From their engagement ring collections to Elsa Peretti designs, Tiffany delivers timeless quality with unmistakable branding, and I dare anyone not get excited when they’re presented with a little blue box featuring the famous mark!
3. Cartier
Best for: High jewelry and French sophistication
If you’re looking for prestige on a global scale, Cartier stands tall. Known for its Panthère collection, Love bracelets, and high-jewelry masterpieces, Cartier is about as exclusive as it gets.
You won’t find budget-friendly options here, but you will find craftsmanship that has attracted royalty, celebrities, and collectors for generations. For those who want a statement piece that instantly communicates status, Cartier remains unmatched.
4. James Allen
Best for: Interactive online ring shopping
James Allen has carved out its niche in the digital space by offering a highly interactive online experience. Their 360° HD diamond viewer lets you inspect stones as if you were holding them under a jeweler’s loupe.
They’re especially popular with millennials and Gen Z shoppers who prefer customization and transparency when buying diamonds. With competitive pricing and a wide selection of lab-grown stones, James Allen makes online jewelry shopping both trustworthy and engaging.
5. De Beers
Best for: Diamond heritage and global authority
Few names carry as much weight in the diamond world as De Beers. For over a century, they’ve been shaping the industry and setting standards for diamond sourcing and marketing.
While they once focused solely on mined stones, De Beers has recently embraced lab-grown diamonds through its Lightbox brand, giving shoppers more choice. Whether you’re looking for an iconic solitaire or a modern fashion piece, De Beers offers luxury with history.
6. Bulgari
Best for: Bold, statement-making designs
Italian jeweler Bulgari is known for its unapologetically bold designs – think vibrant gemstones, chunky gold, and architectural flair. Their Serpenti collection alone has become legendary, winding its way into jewelry history.
For those who want something distinctive, glamorous, and unmistakably European, Bulgari offers jewelry that’s as much art as accessory.
7. Harry Winston
Best for: Red-carpet diamonds and exclusivity
Known as the “King of Diamonds,” Harry Winston has dressed some of the world’s most famous celebrities. Their diamonds are consistently among the best of the best, with a focus on exquisite settings and flawless stones.
This isn’t the place to pop in for a budget gift – Harry Winston is pure luxury. But for those looking for world-class diamonds and a brand synonymous with red-carpet sparkle, it doesn’t get much better.
8. David Yurman
Best for: Contemporary American design
Bridging the gap between fine jewelry and everyday wear, David Yurman has built its reputation on distinctive cable-motif designs. Their pieces balance artistry with wearability, appealing to those who want jewelry that’s both stylish and versatile.
From sterling silver bangles to gemstone cocktail rings, Yurman pieces are instantly recognizable, making them a favorite among those who love contemporary American design.
Wrapping It Up
With so many jewelry stores to choose from, narrowing down your options can feel daunting. But the truth is, each of the names on this list offers something unique, and you can be sure that should you visit any of them to buy your next piece, you will be met with excellent customer service and even better jewelry.
- Tiffany & Co. brings timeless prestige.
- Cartier, Bulgari, and Harry Winston deliver high luxury and exclusivity.
- James Allen and De Beers combine tradition with modern innovation.
- David Yurman offers contemporary design with American flair.
And leading them all? Rogers & Hollands | Ashcroft & Oak. Unlike many luxury-first jewelers, they balance heritage with accessibility. Their guest-first policies, lifetime jewelry protection, and approachable yet diverse selection mean you don’t need a royal budget to buy jewelry with confidence, and you really can be confident that you’ll be buying quality when you choose them.
Whether you’re buying an engagement ring, celebrating an anniversary, or simply investing in a piece that will last a lifetime, Rogers & Hollands | Ashcroft & Oak prove that family-owned values and customer-first service still shine the brightest in 2025.